Jump to content
When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.
  • Current Donation Goals

Franken BK TW Submariner 16610 Review


coolchu001

Recommended Posts

This particular watch is a BK TW with gen crystal, gen bezel insert w/ superlumed pearl, swiss movement, noob hallow mid link bracelet and WM9 clasp. I'm not exactly sure how this particular combo was created but I would assume the gen crystal is to fix the issue with the over sized etching with the rep crystals. The insert of course is to fix the issue of the pearl and perhaps the font of the numbers. The crystal and bezel insert was installed by RSH. The bracelet has ok SEL but I'll go into more detail with that later, as well as the clasp.

Here's a few pictures of the complete watch:

zkypL.jpg

sO8qw.jpg

3y90J.jpg

Glamour shots:

QIHJO.jpg

40vnx.jpg

svp3w.jpg

Wrist shots:

8wFJ6.jpg

AXW1T.jpg

UIbw9.jpg

Keep in mind that this review watch has gen parts so the base TW may not look the same but you can get an idea of what it can be like with gen parts and how it plays with the TW case.

Case:

First off, let's take a look at the case itself.

Here it is on its own without bracelet/strap:

1744f.jpg

You can see that the watch isn't the typical factory watch by examining the bezel edge. It is very well defined and has nice polished/brushed finish.

57Yjd.jpg

You can also see the CG has a more gen like shape and spacing around the crown. Of course it features triple lock like the gen.

Another thing you might notice is the rehaut depth and slope. The rehaut is not shallow nor does it have the slope you see on other reps such as the noob. Another thing worth mentioning is the circle where the crystal meets the case.

v5aFJ.jpg

8dXLC.jpg

You'll see a dark ring around it, BK mentions that this is only possible with a gen like constructed case. This give it a distinctive look that other reps do not have.

KuSWD.jpg

Here you can see the well defined edges and stamping of the crown. The crown has excellent definition on the teeth and the stamping of the logo is sharp.

qdtkn.jpg

It is cleaner than the one on my noob GMT rep that I used to for my review against a gen GMT.

The sides of the case is well made and the polish is quite good.

Ob4FY.jpg

809ph.jpg

The edges of the case is sharp.

Jg8wU.jpg

The noob GMT I reviewed had dull edges and case end while the gen GMT has sharper edges and pointy ends. The TW case does a good job replicating this. The back edge of the case is very sharp and and the ends are pointy. I might say even more pointy than my gen!

The ends have the proper diagonal brushing as per gen.

i7Qri.jpg

The case back has very good finish and the brushing looks spot on with the case back of my gen GMT.

abFtl.jpg

One thing I want to point out is that the case back teeth is well defined and sharp, very gen like quality here.

cQCHV.jpg

However I would like to point out the engravings between the lugs.

The engraving is a bit thin and on my particular case the word design is misspelled as "desing".

gJXxL.jpg

fUk4Z.jpg

I asked BK about this issue and was told this wasn't the case in earlier productions but the issue is present on all the cases he currently has on hand.

Dial/lume/hands:

FPbcQ.jpg

I believe the dial is the standard TW dial with lume done by PBdad (TW sub may come with the WM9 dial).

The font and spacing is spot on with the gen. I noticed that in other reps the "L" in ROLEX is not aligned properly under the Rolex crown logo. The dial is finished in high gloss black with clean dial markers.

You can see that the markers at 12, 6 and 9 have thicker surroundings vs the rounded markers. This is also a unique feature of the TW sub.

http://i.imgur.com/v5aFJ.jpg

The lume application done by PBdad is top notch! Even though it was relumed, the marks do not have the dome/bubble effect. The layer of lume is very consistent and smooth throughout.

The brightness of the lume is almost as good as my gen GMT IIc. The color is a bit darker. The lume matches the gen pearl's lume color perfectly. The lume also lasts overnight, but not as long as my gen.

FqwQN.jpg

TW sub against my gen GMT IIc

lz4Hb.jpg

F5Bx0.jpg

The hands are also superlumed but I'm not sure if it was done by PBdad or the factory. It too has clean application with no lume seen on the edges and glows uniformly with the markers on the dial.

Here's a comparison of the date font compared to my gen GMT IIc. Slightly different, but the printing is very clean and well centered.

JNx0J.jpg

ND95Y.jpg

Crystal (GEN):

The gen crystal sits on the case with the correct height. You can see more of the ring of darkness between the rehaut and the crystal.

JFShy.jpg

miCMc.jpg

Since it's a gen crystal, the etching is only visible through bright light or magnification.

Bezel/pearl (GEN):

I believe the bezel has a gen like construction as well.

NtYp0.jpg

The edges of the case has sharp teeth that are well defined. It feels the same as my gen GMT IIc.

JiGVL.jpg

miCMc.jpg

The insert sits in with a slight recess which is true to the gen. With this recess, it gives an extra sparkle around the insert.

LTaUN.jpg

The operation of the bezel on this particular watch is a bit tight, not sure if that's how it was when it left from BK's hands. However it does not have any play at all! Each click is distinctive.

Here's a shot of the gen pearl. as perfect as one can get biggrin.gif

u7viS.jpg

If any of you are planning to get the gen insert for the TW/WM9 cases, do it! It's worth the investment not having to worry about the pearl! You can pick up mint/new inserts over at TRF for less than $200-250; LV ones would run you maybe $100 more.

Bracelet/clasp (noob/WM9):

The previous owner swapped the TW bracelet and clasp with a noob bracelet and WM9 combo. The noob bracelet has the correct hollow mid links as apposed to the solid ones on the TW bracelet. I had rebrushed the entire bracelet for a more true to gen look.

8JLWt.jpg

vvNfq.jpg

The SEL fitment is not too bad but the spacing between the bracelet and the side of the case can be more leveled.

OCaSo.jpg

I'm not sure how it is with the standard TW bracelet.

YqsmD.jpg

However i find that it is quite easy to remove and install the bracelet. It may be due to the better positioning of the spring bar holes on the case or its spring bars.

vuizR.jpg

I have also repressed the permanent links together with a case press for a tighter fit to give it less sag.

W6CXa.jpg

The WM9 clasp has very good engraving and the joints are well made with very little play.

ICTN9.jpg

3t6do.jpg

Nrm4O.jpg

l3vPH.jpg

However, the space between the two parts of the clasp has brushing that goes perpendicular to the rest of the clasp. This can be fixed by polishing and rebrushing the area in the correct direction.

VcnhV.jpg

Movement:

All BK TW subs come with a verified Swiss movement. This particular one has the 2836 movement. The winding mechanism feels smoother than the Asian movements in my previous Rolex reps. Over the course of 3 days it ran -8 seconds behind my computer's time. This is very good considering it has not been serviced or regulated.

Conclusion:

I enjoy this watch very much for its gen like feel and quality for a fraction of the price of the gen. It is well made and you can feel the high craftsmanship that went into manufacturing the case. After having the bracelet links re-pressed, the presence of the watch on the wrist felt much more solid. One of the issues with Rolex reps that I've own is the bracelet and that is often overlooked.

The only cons that I have with this particular watch would be the lug engraving (not a big issue since you can't see it when a bracelet is installed), and the spacing of the noob bracelet with the TW case. All in all, this was a wise investment for such a high end rep. Saves me from buying the gen biggrin.gif

Hope you guys enjoy this watch review as much as I enjoy the watch it self.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Superb review!!! Excellent detail and some great pics! Thanks for taking the time to do this. It is quite clear how much you like the watch! :tu:

Great review buddy and great pictures,this is perfect timing as I want to purchase a 16610 imminently and I'm not sure what to do but bks is deffinatly an amazing rep with gen insert installed.

Thanks again

Ryan

Excellent review and great detailed pictures! Thanks for posting and congrats on the TW!

Thanks to all the positive comments! I am in process of getting better SEL fitment. I have also reshaped the CG a bit (it's too tall when a gen crown is installed)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks to all the positive comments! I am in process of getting better SEL fitment. I have also reshaped the <acronym title='Crown Guard'>CG</acronym> a bit (it's too tall when a gen crown is installed)

How hard is it to reshape after gen-crown install? BK is doing mine, but i don't know if he also reshape for gen crown fitment

Link to comment
Share on other sites

How hard is it to reshape after gen-crown install? BK is doing mine, but i don't know if he also reshape for gen crown fitment

I just manually sanded the tips to make them flatter and shorter, then sanded the back side to create the slope. The inside was also sanded a bit to create the curves. It's not a difficult process but it takes a lot of time. This was also my first time doing it. After sanding finish off by polishing the CG.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Great review and also a great watch.

Do u noticed that the Datewindow is a bit too small?

That was the reason why I installed the markers of this dial to a

WM9 one that has correct date window!

Believe me the Noob+ WM9 Combination is way better than the TW.

Thanks for this nice review!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Great review and also a great watch.

Do u noticed that the Datewindow is a bit too small?

That was the reason why I installed the markers of this dial to a

WM9 one that has correct date window!

Believe me the Noob+ WM9 Combination is way better than the TW.

Thanks for this nice review!

Is the date window a huge difference? As in the comparison with coolchu's gen the numbering to me looks bigger on the Tw rather than window smaller? Cheers :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Very cool only makes me more and more excited to get mine back from BK and PBdad. BK is installing gen crystal,insert,crown, and tube a long with clarks click spring. also I asked BK to use just a slightly taller gasket to give the date mag a little more pop lets hope that works :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Very cool only makes me more and more excited to get mine back from BK and PBdad. BK is installing gen crystal,insert,crown, and tube a long with clarks click spring. also I asked BK to use just a slightly taller gasket to give the date mag a little more pop lets hope that works :)

Wow that's gonna be another great build.did you supply the gen parts or did bk source them for you?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I've got my local source in town who I can go for parts for all my builds :) only little tiny issue was I did ask my guy for a SL insert and he accidentally got me one with tritium which no longer glows instead of C1-C3 which was no biggie I just sent it off for some PBdad treatment ;)

Wow that's gonna be another great build.did you supply the gen parts or did bk source them for you?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Very cool only makes me more and more excited to get mine back from BK and PBdad. BK is installing gen crystal,insert,crown, and tube a long with clarks click spring. also I asked BK to use just a slightly taller gasket to give the date mag a little more pop lets hope that works :)

I'm waiting on mine too!:D The wait kills..

What did you mean by taller gasket to give the mag a little more pop? Make it sit higher?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I asked BK to do a slightly taller gasket then what he normally uses. taller gasket=stronger date mag. the last time he swapped crystals the xstal was way to low and when he brought it up it did make the mag seem nice and presentable not so much on the weak side :) I think it was a 2.7mm

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I asked BK to do a slightly taller gasket then what he normally uses. taller gasket=stronger date mag. the last time he swapped crystals the xstal was way to low and when he brought it up it did make the mag seem nice and presentable not so much on the weak side :) I think it was a 2.7mm

I agree. Have seen some subs with thedate mag sitting too low kinda like non-existent. If i'm not wrong the gen sits quite high right?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 year later...

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...
Please Sign In or Sign Up