Well said on all accounts Legend, DEFINITELY very model specific. JF has better crystals, straps, and clasps indeed.
I too HATE the JF datewheel font though! Noob does pay a bit more attention to small details and dial colors I think.
However, in the Rubberclad situation (OP's question), exactly as you stated - I feel the JF is the better choice as the most important aspect to me above all else is the closer rubber coated steel bezel instead of having a Roo "Plastic-clad".
Cheers!