Who has best SMP rep (not chrono)

[jomama]

I am going to get the SMP rep (decided with all your help). But now debating from who?

I assumed Josh's and Andrew were the exact same watch (same factory etc) but in looking at the product description, it appears the size is different. Andrews says 42.5 and 14 thick and Joshs says 41 and 12 thick. Do you think this is an oversight n one of their part or are they different? Which is more accurate and why would they be different if movement is the same.

Second, Andrew says he has light AR on crystal. Both appear to have same pearl and alignment issue.

Is there another SMP out there that is better than these?

As a wildhair, Highflyingclive loves this),I like Andrews SMP GMT but it has solid caseback and my understanding is the gen has a display caseback. Josh has the GMT with display caseback but has gold movement vs silver color as gen has. Anyone know if the GEN SMP GMT comes with a solid caseback? This might be a good option if gen has solid as well as I like the red in the dial and SMP is pretty common.

Thanks in advance!

[omeega]

I got one of Josh's, excellent service, but the watch is missing the 3o'clock hour marker and of course the bezel is misaligned and the bracelet has screws. I would try and source it with the hour marker.