Jump to content
When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

madmex

Member
  • Posts

    216
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by madmex

  1. The 36mm ceramic seamaster that trusty has is amazing.  I wish that maker would make the 41mm version. There is a 41mm version made by BP which is nowhere as good.  The Miyota 9015 does not have any stutter.  The Miyota 8025 in the V6F has stutter because it has indirect seconds by design and there is play within the gearing.

  2. Wow really? I hope that AP could rep the JF version one day then :lol:

     

    But seriously I agree that in terms of overall finishing, JF is better. But it just has flaws that are egregious to me. To each their own. As long as you enjoy your watch, and share your thoughts with the community sincerely, it is much appreciated. :)

     

     

     

    Message crafted while wrestling a juvenile crocodile that's unwilling to be captured and made into leather

    Lol yeah Idk how I put that the dial detail is better than gen.  I meant it is better than TF. :D woops

    Yes, that is what I just researched.  My dealer will have a Blue TF in tomorrow for review.  I wanted white as I thought that was the best dial.  Do you have a Blue dial TF....is it very good to excellent?  I have read that the AP Blue is the most difficult to replicate..thus some debate as to it being an ultimate tell.  As an aside, I offered to 'take' a Patek 5711 Nautilus in Blue or White with the decorated bridges as a replacement.  Thiose two are out of stock too. Bummer.  I expect to receive a few photos of the TF version tomorrow.  Thoughts on Blue over White from TF?

    I had a blue dial TF and I can say that I enjoyed it more than the white TF.  The blue dial was magical although indeed different than gen. I think the JF blue is closer, although perhaps nicer, deeper, than the gen so not quite accurate either.

     

    As far as V6F and TF I believe the dials are the same.  Someone has said the bracelets are the same as well--and that is a very nice bracelet if you get one that is symmetric (I got one that was mismatched on one side of the case on my TF).  I like the TF bracelet flexibility better than JF.

     

    V6F case shape is better than TF, but it's thicker my a millimeter and change.  As far as dials... despite the tappiserie size (accurate for other Royal Oaks not this one) being too small, it feels gen-like.

     

     

     

    • Like 1
  3. I just received my JF 15400 and I must say after owning two TF versions (A2824 and Miyota), the JF has the best attention to finishing details and case tolerances. JF has a lot of AP experience. The recessed screws are spot on, the lines are as good as gen, the dial detail is more accurate than gen, while the tapisserie indeed is smaller, it is highly detailed moreso than TF and V6F.   The dial pops much more and the watch feels better quality.  Both of my TF watches had different issues that wouldn't be found in gen watches (the case lines didn't match the bezel/midcase/caseback), the cases had differing levels of assymetry and irregular fit.  The bracelet was very flexible and I'm afraid more so than the JF version although the JF finish is great.  The thickness is not as bad as V6F, but I have not personally measured it yet.

    As far as the screws on the clasp, it appears that JF purchased a watch and while the screws are incorrect to the TF version, they are correct to the latest iterations of the 15400, so the clasp is in fact correct.  I personally would not buy another TF 15400, 2 was enough and they both disappointed me personally by having fit and finish issues.  The BP case looks nice too but the dial and movement are off. The movement was undecorated which would never be the case with an AP.  At least the Miyota TF and A2824 were very nicely decorated.

     

     

    • Like 1
  4. This is my case back, thought it looked pretty good. I don't know what the end links are. My pearl seems good, very well centered. I'm new at this and easy to please too.

     

    7a8d8cb6c35ae45fc36544ac964aea05.jpg

     

     

    Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

    ceramic-back.jpg~original

    The end-links are the part of the bracelet where it attaches to the case.  You can see from the back that the shiny parts on the front are actually separate pieces of metal.

     

    Here you can see that the waves are supposed to look like waves in the sand.  They are not bad on your watch. On some reps they are shiny wavy lines like this disgrace from the BP factory:

    post-52261-0-85711600-1375187556.jpg

     

     

    IMG_5412_zpse09cd4bc.jpg

    The pearl is different too.  Yours isn't bad either

     

    It's nice that yours works as it should without the frozen subdial.

  5. There are two versions.  

    The one that uses the 7753 works as gen does--subdial at 3 works, date is corrected via pushbutton recessed on helium escape valve.  It is the OP's watch.  

    The inaccuracies:  

    • The end links are one solid piece.  
    • The caseback wave pattern
    • The pearl

    The 7750 version is made by BP factory, it has 5 piece end links (with 4 polished metal inserts) as gen, and the caseback is beautifully replicated, the pearl is also very good.

    Inaccuracies:

    • 7750 movement, frozen sub-dial at 3

     

     

  6. The dial is very accurate. It has not changed. Differences noticed in the past in the minute track, hour markers, date font are all correct per gen.

    They are different gen editions. if they "change the dial" it won't be per gen bc they already replied from a gen and they aren't likely to purchase another one to appease everyone.

    This one rocks.

  7. Go view a Gen then compare , that's why I canned my order and got the Panda 44 , unless they've changed the dial. :)

    Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

     

    The maker used a gen watch, but the one they purchased is from the initial batch.  It is a very accurate dial, true to the gen that was used.  Note the date font is correct as well.  ;)

     

    Here is the gen:

     

    6713e037-41d9-43b0-8c3f-3d16a70865a1_zps

     

    here's the one on my wrist for the last 49 hrs

     

    53172A23-EE58-49AB-82C5-302C9DAAF41C_zps

     

    7AAC8E37-38E9-4089-9B0E-D4553A75C7AD_zps

     

    IMG_1182_zps721c9b84.jpg

     

    That said... the panda is nice too!

  8. I think what happens is the orders keep piling and when stock comes it's mostly accounted for.  I placed my order a week after it came out and barely got QC the last few days--so I've been waiting for almost a month.  If you place order when stock comes in it may already be sold out.  

  9. The rehaut alignment, bezel alignment and text on the dial are great.  The batch is very inconsistent and I can say yours is probably the best I've seen.

     

    Here's mine that I approved last night.

     

    IMG_0047_zps285f2db2.jpg

    The crown on your bracelet is applied very cleanly as well.  I would personally accept.  

  10. can I ask when you ordered? Trying to get an idea how long mine will take to come

     

    I had preordered well before Chinese New Year (CNY).  I believe the next stocks are fulfilling pre-orders as well--maybe enough for new orders.  I ordered from PureTime (Angus).  What I like is the included 2 ATM pressure test which they send you pictures during QC to show that it passed the test.  It's invaluable for a pricey rep, to know that it can withstand a 50 m dash in the rain!  They do that for all watches.  

     

    That said, perhaps the dealers that didn't pre-order will have the ability to sell it on demand.  

  11. And fwiw , PT have supposedly refunded me last thursday, but they tell me today the credit back to my credit card takes 30 days, is this fact or fiction ?

    Pt is one of the biggest TDs with a reputation to keep. I wouldn't rest at ease and there's a reason he is a TD. You'll get your refund. Unfortunately probably will be less than you paid based

×
×
  • Create New...
Please Sign In or Sign Up