Posting a thread for this was in my opinion silly. If Hike had stiffed him completely, a true scam, then yes. But this seems a little like a temper tantrum. I believe Hike that the scratches may have happened during shipping. Why wouldn't he disclose? Would he get $25 or $30 less? Maybe. I had a guy sell me two watches - one showed up completely dead and the other was running two hours fast per day! I gave him a bad review to warn others, but I would never open a thread. That said, I do understand being a bit disappointed at the scratches, the refund offer should have taken care of that. There, I'm done:)