The construction may not be accurate, but side by side, the MBW definitely looks more like the part IMO. I have both the sec@9 and sec@12 and have compared them to a buddy's gen. The sec@9 has more accurate dimensions, better engraving, better polished edges and more accurate looking bezel screws. But I guess it's all a matter of opinion on which is "better" since they are still both just reps.