Agreed. I have a gen Rolex, Cartier etc. But I feel that buying good reps is good too, ESP in developing countries and when you travel to certain places. It wouldn't feel as bad if u got robbed or if u bang it accidentally due to the bumpy ride. For me, it's more of a risk management thing. I'd wear the gen as frequent as I wear the reps, but it matters where I go. I don't see it as if u can't afford it, don't pretend like you can, but more so as a means to maximize our happiness while managing risks:D and as you said, keeping your rep to have it knocked around serves its function well but again, a watch is a status symbol. So see it as u may.
This forum is great though, and the people are helpful