Browsing through various watch forums, I took notice of the Russian watches. The unique military look of some of the brands and Russian writing brough back a lot of the memories from my younger years, as such watches were not rare in the Southeastern Europe. Thus I spent more and more time exploring the current offering of Russian watch brands, especially the ones like Vostok, having various military pictures on the dials.
Vostok Amphibian (or Amphibia) series are one of the cheapest gen automatics on the market today, with prices hovering around $60. I really had to have one, both because I really like that retro look and because I wanted to compare the build quality and overall feeling against best cheap reps (like Narikaa's Planet Ocean or Noobmariner). I could already see myself building quite a collection of Amphibians.
Currently there are 2 types of cases for Amphibians: round one and more bulky rectangular one, called "Ministry". The other popular type of Vostoks is called Komandirskie; they are around $40, but have manual wind movements and the cases are not stainless steel. However, there is much more interesting dial selection there than in Amphibians (although some sellers are willing to make some dial swaps).
So, this is the first one I ordered, Vostok Amphibian 2416/710335:
On paper, the specs look fine:
stainless steel case and bracelet31 jewel automatic movement (21600 bph)waterproof 200 mdomed mineral crystal
The only thing that bothered me was the size, it is only 40 mm wide, but the Ministry case did not look so small on the pictures, so I hoped that the watch will fit fine on my 18 cm (~7 inch) wrist.
The big day came, and I started to unwrap the package. And then the dissapointements started coming: the watch box is crappy plastic, goes straight to trashthe bracelet is extremely crappy, feels like a plastic toy. Totaly unwearable, goes straight to trash. This made me appreciate the worst bracelet I have encountered previously (hollow-link Noobmariner's); it feels like a million bucks after this junk.the watch without bracelet is very light, definitely not what I expect from a stainless steel watch. This is probably due to a simple movement and thin case.the crown looks and feels like it is made from tin, and not SS, and that a stronger pressure would deform itthe crown is extremely loose (think about a tooth which is ready to fall out), and the watch will wind only if slight pressure inwards is applied when in winding position. I have no idea how could they implement 200 m water proofing with such crappy component. Though, I read on WUS Russian watches forum that the crown is intentionally made this way, to somehow increase the sturdiness of the watch... Go figure.there is no quick-set date position, you have to continiously change the time from 22:00 to 4:00 and back to set it.bezel has no click, it is moved continiouslythe lume is not much better than standard rep oneoverall, the watch feels very, very cheap (which it is, to be honest)
On the positive side:
[*]the dial is flat (no raised indices), but it is very crisp and interesting, with 1, 5, 7, 9 and 11 gold markers shining differently depending on the angle of viewing[*]the domed crystal also looks very nice in the combination with the dial[*]the second-hand moves reasonably smooth considering the low bph
Despite a long list of bad stuff, the watch still looks rather nice, and I really wanted to wear it, at least as a dirty work beater and for swimming. So, I ordered a black nylon Nato strap from Gnomon, the combination with this watch seemed quite decent on the pictures. Big mistake - this has made an already too light watch even lighter on the wrist, and I like my watches and bracelets to be as heavy as possible. Note: this was my first encounter with nylon straps on the watches, so if you like those, you may get a different experience; this Gnomon strap seems to be well built, and I had pleasant experience when ordering from them.
The size also bothered me, it wears smaller than Noobmariner, for example, which I feel is already bordeline small for my wrist. The rectangular case did not help much, as the dial itself is smaller by a mm or two than the Noobmariner's, and that makes the watch visually small.
The epilogue? I wore the watch exactly once, and it went straight to the bottom of the drawer - until my wife dug it out and claimed it for herself. It really looks much nicer on a small women's wrist than on mine. How it compares to Noobmariner and POrikaa? It can't compare, these two watches are better by orders of magnitude. Note that this Vostok is around $70 shipped, and those two reps are around $100 shipped, but adding a new bracelet or strap to Vostok erases the difference. Too bad that the build quality of these Vostoks is so low, otherwise I would really enjoy building a small collection because of their unique dials (search for Tank, Scuba Dude or Submarine dials to see some of the most popular ones).
(Pictures borrowed from www.smirs.com and www.russian-watches.info. Please note that the colors in the first one seem to be the most accurate to reality; the ones below are a bit washed out.)
If anyone is interested, I can add a couple of size comparison pics with some of the well-known reps.