That is such a great thread to read. Thanks for everyone who has chimed in until now, I will also share my view on that topic now. You can not make me stop!
I've been in several discussions with people all over the rep and gen forums (especially on RWI, I'm sure y'all know why) where I've seen a lot of [censored] happening like i.e. a no profiteering rule but then seeing WM9 TTs sell at 1.2k stock with slight mods. And seeing a Noob v3 based franken SubC with the case being valued at $350.
Now guess which sale got flamed? Yeah, the SubC because that case is an old rep case and bla bla. That is totally okay since these WM9's are rare as hens teeth nowadays and still the BEST OTB rep of the 16613 unless you build so are the v3 cases.
As someone else already said above that's supply and demand. Which again is totally alright.
Now seeing all this from the genuine / parts POV:
If one bought a 1680 RedSub for let's say $250 back in the days, would it be profiteering nowadays if he sold it for the market value? Would YOU sell it for the same amount in 2016, you bought it for in the 70ies? I doubt it. That's just the market again.
Same thing with parts, if one can source parts to modern or vintage parts no matter what he paid for it, the demand for it is there and if the people that want it decide they're ready to pay $3000 for a Hulk dial, then so be it, you can't change it even if the seller bought it for $1000 or whatever.
I'm calling [censored] on all this profiteering bs that's all around lately. Sure it's not okay to sell a rep (current) that cost you $500 for $550.
/rant