Mark I am not gonna answer to everything that you said above. I never mentioned names or that I had a problem.
If you have a problem with a member at TRC keep it there and don't bring it over. I am not registered there and don't give a [censored] about what happened there as long as it stays there. Did I said 'there' enough times?
Conclusion:
1. I said:
Yes.. plus a few scratches on the hands and 'maybe' dial (inevitable on the relume)
2. The Zigmeister said:
if you can't accept the minor scratches then dont' get your watch relumed, that message is clear and up front before any lume is applies.....no complaints so far, so it must be acceptable to those getting it done, or they would not be coming back for more...
3. Finepics said:
What The Zigmeister says about the gold hands is true "As for the hands, you will get minor scratches, but if you consider that you have to physically remove the lume with a knife, and handle the hands, there is no way to not have Minor scratches..." - they are plated in 24ct gold which means the plating is very soft and marks very easily. There is no way to polish them if marks are there
Really speaking if you want perfect looking numbers etc in daylight then buy a gen or get a rep but do not lume it. If you want it to be more like the gen (and I am talking PAM's here as the lume is what they are reknowned for) then have it lumed but accept that under a loupe (in most cases) it will not look like it's been applied by a machine. Look: we are dealing with reps here, most people looking at a watch will not be wearing loupes so will not see some of the things we do. Unless you are trying to pass it on as the real thing (as does happen and these enhancements only help increase the value!!!) stop looking too closely and enjoy the upgraded watch - remember though that it is a FAKE whatever you have had done to it.
So please we all said the same things... This is not a debate between anyone and who is better.
You both do what it possibly can be done by hand and this is 'not' Perfect as you both said.
People understand it, and people don't.
People will still continue to relume their watches and others won't.
CASE CLOSED