Help me choose C Sub rep?

[DiverDoc]

As possibly the noobiest noob here, I've spend the last few days reading posts & reviews in my search for a basic black C Sub rep with Swiss 2836 movement, and I've pretty much narrowed the list to BK and Andrew/Trusty.  Both watches look great to my admittedly novice eyes, and both BK and Andrew have (from what I've read here) impeccable reputations.  Prices, including shipping, are not too far apart. 

 

So then, can you folks tell me anything that might be a tipping point favoring one or the other?

 

Thanks!