Which 42 Po? And Why?

[palhaco02]

I'm interested in a PO. Since my wrist is (I think) small for the 45 PO, the 42 seems the best choice.

But as all the topics agree the "ultimate" PO is the best, the 42 PO as different versions with different prices (and quality?).

I'm going crazy since I can't find the gen's specifications and do not know the different movements.

On one hand we have this one: http://watchwindersworld.com/omse10010-sea...242-p-1432.html

And it fits a 2824 ETA, which makes it 12 mm thick. this will set me back $228

On the other hand, we have this one: http://www.silix-prime.com/product.asp?id=1318

Which runs on a 2836 ETA and makes it 10mm thick. This costs only $150

Visually I cannot spot any difference beside the case back.

Both claim saphire with AR.

Please help me to choose one, the other or wait for the "ultimate" 42.

Which movement is better? which thickness is closer to gen?

If any of you has access to both could you make a comparison?

Thanks!!

PS:

I thought I showed some homework before someone sent me to the search button

[Fireman_Fred]

I bought a 42mm (black bezel/orange numbers) from Paul at Wo-Mart - It's a fantastic watch and (to my untrained eye), appears t have very good AR. According to Paul's website it has an ETA2824 movement and is a lot cheaper than Josh or Andrew.

Incidentally, I have also just received a 45.5mm Orange bezel PO from Silix-Prime and I actually prefer the 42mm !