TeeJay,
I signed up in Mid March in this forum, Mid Feb in two others, and Mid Jan on another (I can guarantee you though that I have read damn near every post in all four forums )
I have also immersed myself fully into this hobby. I have purchased twelve reps since January, all from various people and dealers, and I'm still going strong. I only buy from dealers/sources with good reviews, and like everyone else, hope for the best. For instance, regardless of quality or price, I would not buy from a "certain" dealer. I have seen from my research that he has certain customer service issues. He may be the best guy in the world, and have a great record of sales and quality, but I'm not willing to take the chance I catch him on a bad day. He, however, has access to MBW. Well, I'll wait until I go to Thailand, or until a member sells one to get my MBW sub
Good point on the Cartel. This is where I believe the buyer has all the power. You can be sure that the minute I'm stung by the Cartel, my business will go elsewhere. I like it just like it is... a couple reputable indy dealers, a couple of reputable Cartel dealers. Lot's of selection. I'm the type of guy who won't fly Delta Air anymore because they took my 90+K miles without warning, and then sent me a flyer to buy back my miles at some ridiculous price. They lost my business forever, United and American gained a loyal customer.
Andrew and Josh are the two guys I send my friends to when they want to buy a rep. Reasonable price, good selection, well laid out site, online payment, reliable shipping. Easy transaction. If they want more, I advise them to click on the RG and RWI links.... That's how I started. Look at me now.... Member in all four main forums, a ton of watches, a full mod/repair toolkit set up, learning how to repair watches... As my wife and kids say... obsessed with watches.
As for Angus, I've heard nothing but good about him, I'm looking for an excuse to buy from him. Sounds like I may have one soon!
I am envious that the OP was able to actually meet one of the reputable dealers. I'd love that opportunity, or the opportunity for a factory tour.