Yes,
I dont expect the rep to be made 100% true to a gen, but i woudl expect it to be made true to itself. IE, I know it may have glaring differences (IE wrong date font) from a GEN because it is a rep. However, i was not sure if having a flaw like a dirty dial would be a flaw, or something you just deal with.
Another example: I recently brought replica plastics for my motorcycle. I knew they woudnt fit like the Honda manufactured ones, but I woudnt accept paint drips, or decals with bubbles under them.
I take it from you guys that the only reason to return a rep is a show stopper of sorts (something that stops you from wearing the watch, or really non functional). I can accept that, I just wanted a better idea of what the community standards are.