Dials battle! MBW vs Noobmariner dial

[vmena]

Always heard that Noob's dial is the cream of the cream of the rep dials... I made a comparison pic with both dials to facilitate discussion on the board post opinions please (pics are not the best but I guess they will do the trick)

[predfan2001]

I am not a big fan of the Noob dial. It looks good for what it is but not the best. The "S" in submariner is spaced out too far and slightly crooked. If you zoom in on this you can spot a Noob dial every time.

[Jon Doh]

The one on the left has the correct size and type dots.

[crystalcranium]

I was facinnated by a member comparison detailing many photos of genuine submariners over the years that showed very plainly examples of variation in the production the real deal. Some of this variation just might cause the more stringent among us to doubt authenticity in a side by side. I'm pretty certain a crooked S has showed up on a genuine dial every now and then.

[vmena]

I thought I was the only one thinking that the noob dial is not so good as everybody say. For me, is not worth the effort/money you may invest replacing MBW dial (left in pics) by the noob one.