Help me chose between these

[kavaron]

I want to buy a nice watch for my friend who is 35 years old and dresses with costumes almost every day. I am between these 3 watches from Eddie Lee

1. AP rose gold limited edition

http://s12.photobucket.com/albums/a210/sun...%20ROSE%20GOLD/

2. Patek 5053

http://s12.photobucket.com/albums/a210/sun...Y/PATEK%205053/

3. Patek 5054

http://s12.photobucket.com/albums/a210/sun...Y/PATEK%205054/

I think the patek 5054 and 5053 are fantasy watches? But what about the AP rose gold?

Thanks in advance

PS. password for EL's site is "ok"

[eLiNK]

I want to buy a nice watch for my friend who is 35 years old and dresses with costumes almost every day. I am between these 3 watches from Eddie Lee

1. AP rose gold limited edition

http://s12.photobucket.com/albums/a210/sun...%20ROSE%20GOLD/

2. Patek 5053

http://s12.photobucket.com/albums/a210/sun...Y/PATEK%205053/

3. Patek 5054

http://s12.photobucket.com/albums/a210/sun...Y/PATEK%205054/

I think the patek 5054 and 5053 are fantasy watches? But what about the AP rose gold?

Thanks in advance

PS. password for EL's site is "ok"

5054 is for sure a fantasy watch.

As to the other two, no clue.

Gran could tell you more on AP, as he has a SS version in his collection.

[ehtolcad]

that AP is not fantasy it's a copy of the audemars piguet jules audemars

[gran]

The "PATEK 5053" is the most beautiful of them all the sun is a giveaway on the otherwise smashingly beautiful "Patek 5054"

Peronally I would have bought the AP JA Limited edition betwen the three

g. (I am an AP JA lover)

[eLiNK]

a picture of the genuine AP (3120)

[eLiNK]

BTW, the size of the genuine watch is 38.7 mm.

How big is the rep?

[SubFrog]

I have an AP rep (picture above) that is very close to that one. However, In place of the word Automatic, I have a subdial for the minutes rather than around the bezel edge.

It's one of my favorites to wear. Especially for a casual to dressy occasion. However, I don't know the exact size of the rep. Looks the same.

I say AP!

[addingwatch]

AP is definitely the way to go. The other two are not even close to the real thing. You may also want to consider some of the rep VC's. They are also very good.

Regards.