New Submariner Tudor 7928 with chapter dial : decent or not ?

[cousin_hub]

Hi fellows

 

A new vintage Submariner Tudor 7928 (little sister of the 5513) on Josh website :

http://www.p-cls.com/tuv01001-vintage-5514-style-date-submariner-asia-2836-28000-p-14543.html

 

What do you think of it?  Decent ? Is it a good basis ?

 

[alligoat]

Same old fat and stubby crown guards.

Crown may or may not be too tall (thick).

Pretty deep rehaut

A slow beat movement would be better

Seems like JJ improved the case by trimming the case at the tube, therefore setting the crown closer to the case, worked the cgs inside and out and shortened the crown- turned the bottom in a lathe.

But if you're just looking for a beater, it might be ok- who questions a Tudor?

[cousin_hub]

Thanks 

but if you compare with the pictures of the previous line of vintage 5513 the crown seems smaller and the lugs thinner 

 

 

http://www.p-cls.com/0rlsv01008-vintage-5513-date-submariner-asia-2836-pi-9480.html?image=6

 

http://www.p-cls.com/tuv01001-vintage-5514-style-date-submariner-asia-2836-28000-pi-14543.html?image=6

Same old fat and stubby crown guards.
Crown may or may not be too tall (thick).
Pretty deep rehaut
A slow beat movement would be better

Seems like JJ improved the case by trimming the case at the tube, therefore setting the crown closer to the case, worked the cgs inside and out and shortened the crown- turned the bottom in a lathe.

But if you're just looking for a beater, it might be ok- who questions a Tudor?

[cousin_hub]

When you compare I don't find it so bad 

 

 

[cousin_hub]

A chapter ring dial :