Jump to content
When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.
  • Current Donation Goals

DSL VS. Cable Modem


jraines87

Recommended Posts

Does anyone have a recomendation on some heavy bandwidth sites I can visit?

I usually download several things at once just to make sure. Normally I'd do a developer's kit from Apple, because, like Microsoft, they use Akamai caching which gives you huge potential download speeds, and I grab a FreeBSD install ISO from the server that gives the best speed according to /usr/ports/sysutils/fastest_cvsup and maybe something from somewhere completely unrelated, like ... um google video?

All throughout this, I'd use net_snmp and MRTG to monitor my bandwidth on my server/router. As long as I can sustain over 12Mbps, I'm happy. My connection is supposedly 24Mbps, but I rarely peak close to 16-18Mbps.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Try MS. They have all kinds of SDKs for download and their servers are up to the demands.

That's because they don't use their own servers. They use Akamai who host local caches in almost every ISP on the planet. This means you get almost full-speed no matter where the servers you're hitting are.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I

usually download several things at once just to make sure. Normally I'd do a developer's kit from Apple, because, like Microsoft, they use Akamai caching which gives you huge potential download speeds, and I grab a FreeBSD install ISO from the server that gives the best speed according to /usr/ports/sysutils/fastest_cvsup and maybe something from somewhere completely unrelated, like ... um google video?

All throughout this, I'd use net_snmp and MRTG to monitor my bandwidth on my server/router. As long as I can sustain over 12Mbps, I'm happy. My connection is supposedly 24Mbps, but I rarely peak close to 16-18Mbps.

Can you repeat this in english. :huh:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

i suppose you are a US resident? i always laughed my ass off, when i heared in those comercials "DSL, 2x faster than CABLE!!"

or when ppl said "yes, we are on a cable connections, thats way faster than DSL"

but i guess it's the fault of the commercials...

lets clear some things up, DSL can be faster than Cable, but Cable can be faster than DSL!

why? because your ISP sets the bandwith you can use.

for example my DSL connection has 6mbit Downstream and 512kbit Upstream, while our Cable provider only offers up to 2mbit down and 512kbit up.

but there are other cable providers who offer 6mbit downstream also. and there are DSL providers who only offer 1mbit DSL. even my DSL provider offers 1, 2, 3 and 6Mbit. end of this year, they told me, they have their new 50mbit DSL ready. cable companies told me they will have something similar available.

so you cant really say "DSL is faster" or "Cable is faster" - it all depends on the plan you have with your ISP :)

and as for heavy bandwith:

fileporn.org ;)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

that is probably,because you live too far away from the VST/TE!

Distance from exchange : 1195 metres

Attenuation : 16 dB

Attainable bitrate	1066 kb/s (up)	 18353 kb/s (down)

So, no, I'm not too far away. The problem is genuinely filling 18Mbps (the real speed of my 24Mbps+ connection) is not easy. My DSLAM is local, the line is clean, etc., but I'm not the only person on the internet. I'm what, 50:1 contention?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well, I finally switched to DSL after 6 or 7 years of cable modem and it's much faster.

Does anyone have a recomendation on some heavy bandwidth sites I can visit?

I'm supposed to get 10mb of download speed with this new DSL :thumbsupsmileyanim:

I know you didn't say this but...

DSL typically (In the united states) has lower available bandwidth but better latency. OTOH Cable can get slow if everyone in your neighborhood is downloading porn. In EU countries DSL can get to much higher speeds than available here :(

I've got 30 mbps download, 5 mbps upload speed with FIOS (Verizon), runs me less than $100 a month.

Rumor is that fios will be available by the end of the year with 100mbps to the home at a low cost.

Unfortunately it costs verizon so much money to install all the fiber, and a lot of time putting it in the ground, they're only able to do <2 mill homes per year.

Edited by mysql
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Distance from exchange : 1195 metres

Attenuation : 16 dB

Attainable bitrate	1066 kb/s (up)	 18353 kb/s (down)

So, no, I'm not too far away. The problem is genuinely filling 18Mbps (the real speed of my 24Mbps+ connection) is not easy. My DSLAM is local, the line is clean, etc., but I'm not the only person on the internet. I'm what, 50:1 contention?

you only get top download rates (25-50mbit) when you are 100-200meters from your DSLAM with VDSL :) at 1.5km you wont get better speed than DSL2.0.

my friend has 50mbit VDSL and he can download with ~48mbit/s real speed! but the DSLAM is right on his porch i think :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Earth to everyone......

I know the difference between DSL and Cable...

My cable provider was sucking ass for about 4 months now (I was on the 5mb download) plan and switched over to DSL 10mb download plan..

I wanted some sites that measure bandwidth to see if I was in fact getting close to the advertised 10mb download speed.

I had two sites myself, but just didn't know if anyone had other suggestion....

And the winner is............

Ethan :thumbsupsmileyanim:

Cool site...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

you only get top download rates (25-50mbit) when you are 100-200meters from your DSLAM with VDSL :) at 1.5km you wont get better speed than DSL2.0.

I'm on ADSL2+ in France. €30 a month for 24Mbps, 100 TV channels over DSL and IP Phone (free calls) ... oh, and a fixed IP with reverse DNS.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

thats pretty cheap... well its expensive considdering you can get 100mbit for less in japan ;)

anyways, DSL2.0 actualy just provides 12-16mbit, BUT (!!) its possible to get up to 25mbit out of DSL2.0 with some kind of update, dont know anything about the update and reliability though! I'd prefer VDSL :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Earth to everyone......

I know the difference between DSL and Cable...

My cable provider was sucking ass for about 4 months now (I was on the 5mb download) plan and switched over to DSL 10mb download plan..

I wanted some sites that measure bandwidth to see if I was in fact getting close to the advertised 10mb download speed.

I had two sites myself, but just didn't know if anyone had other suggestion....

And the winner is............

Ethan :thumbsupsmileyanim:

Cool site...

To start.

http://reviews.cnet.com/7004-7254_7-0.html

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yep, that is one of the two links I used.

Check out ethan's post. That's a great site for testing bandwidth.

I am happy with mine. i consider 1.5Mb and down slow. I never go down 3.8Mb. I am happy with it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...
Please Sign In or Sign Up