Aftermarket 5513 Bezels

[ww12345]

Anybody used these? I know Clarks used to carry some (though I didn't see any in his store at the moment) and Mr Slimeball in TX, but anybody use either of these?

 

http://www.ebay.com/itm/Bezel-Combo-Set-for-Fit-Rolex-Old-Submariner-Black-Silver-5513-/290738599092?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item43b15ef4b4

 

http://www.ebay.com/itm/Stainless-Steel-Rotating-Bezel-W-Retainer-Insert-For-Rolex-5513-1680-Black-/111398427326?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item19efdd1abe

 

Barring either of these, which is the least likely to cause any problems? I know the saying with reps - that there are no guarantees as to parts fitting - but are there some bezels that will cause less trouble than others?

[jackflash]

First link doesn't include the retaining ring. Would suggest buying the second to ensure there are no compatibility issues.

[ww12345]

Cool - I didn't even notice that. Would the second one be better than the Clark's/WSO? I know there are some issues with those requiring a retaining ring mod...

[automatico]

I agree...it's better to buy the complete set rather than parts and hope they fit.

The 'watchman408' set on eBay looks like it might have a matte finish like Clark and ST bezel sets. If so, it is probably the same set and I have had good luck with them.

 

Even when the crystal retainer bezels are oem spec, the differences in case neck od and crystal skirt thickness of aftmkt parts can make fitting it all together a hassle. You need to install the crystal on the case, then measure the od of the crystal with a digital caliper and compare it with the id of the crystal retainer bezel before trying to press the retainer bezel down over the crystal. If it is much more than .1mm difference you may crack the crystal skirt.

Catch 22...this depends on if the crystal is loose or tight on the case neck. Loose needs a tighter fit between the mounted crystal and retainer bezel so it will squeeze the crystal down on the case neck. There is not much of a fix for a retainer bezel that is too loose on the crystal, you will need to find a crystal with a thicker skirt.

 

It might take three crystals...

One to sacrifice when fitting/removing etc.

One to use on the watch.

One for a spare...because the next batch of crystals may not be made to the same specs.  

[dbane883]

Clarks/ST bezels do not accept gen inserts without some surgery.

[tmg]

An MBW bezel assembly seems to have better fitment than a Clarks or if you can get a Yuki or NDT assembly only?? that should work well too.

[ww12345]

Oh, I didn't realize that Yuki or NDT would sell bezel only... That might be an option.

 

Thanks for all the advice!

[jackflash]

One tip that can help to fit the retaining ring, is to put the mid-case with fitted crystal in the freezer, and the retaining ring in the oven, on a low heat, for a few minutes. This will contract the crystal and mid-case, and expand the retaining ring enough to ease fitment.

[Chuck P]

I don't know if Yuki sells the assemblies only? I know they used to sell 1665 bezel assemblies but have not had those in stock for a long time. Don't know about 1680.