BP FF vintage: Phong vs Yuki

[ghost]

Does anyone know if the source is essentially the same? They look very similar.

Yuki sports a AS (A. Schild) automatic movement 1709 GY.

 

Not sure what phong's sports but it's supposedly the same AS movement as the ones the gens used to sport (AS1700/1; 1360N)

 

http://www.yukiwatch.com/catalog/item/7617720/8946447.htm

 

http://jewelryandwatch.com/contents/en-us/d175.html

 

$890 vs $950

 

Thinking of buying one to franken

[whoopy12]

Hey T,

 

They are the same. Though as far as accuracy goes, it is waaaay off from any of the Blancpain models. Unfortunately, your only other rep option is Davidsens, which is also off. Need to make some nice vintage reps eh!

[ghost]

Thanks C. You are the authority on these!

[Dan71]

Hey T,

 

They are the same. Though as far as accuracy goes, it is waaaay off from any of the Blancpain models. Unfortunately, your only other rep option is Davidsens, which is also off. Need to make some nice vintage reps eh!

so ,  do you say that the pics of yuki are fake ? because its seem very accurate to gen ..

[Nightwatch]

Isn´t Davidssen just 1/3 the price of the others? If all are "wrong" how does it hold up than?

More of a rhetoric question - the gen vintages are incredibly beautiful.

[alt.watch.obsessive]

Hey Nightwatch,

Shoot me a PM. I have a beautifully modded version of the phong/yuki that I can talk to you about. 

Cheers. 

[alt.watch.obsessive]

Sorry...addressing the OP ghost.