I used to have the genuine piece, and both versions of the rep.
The genuine one was stunning, with the high quality Maltese cross bracelet, and the Maltese cross bezel. It was the perfect balance of VC tradition and sportiness, with the Maltese cross motif being depicted throughout the entire watch, while you could do some intense sport activities with it (I played golf with it, swam with it, went light diving with it, went jogging with it, but at the same time wore it to formal events and the like).
The replica versions of this watch with the diamond cut bracelet was also absolutely stunning, but the case size was lacking a bit, and the clasp was incorrect, but to be honest, I like the old VC Overseas clasp more than the current ones, since the current clasps don't feel very secure.
But I sold the genuine one off in the end, because I decided it really wasn't what I was looking for. I just felt it copied the Royal Oak too much in terms of case design, and out of the whole luxury SS market, the Overseas was more a follower to the Royal Oak and the Nautilus, and I prefer watches that are more radical in deisgn, they are innovators, they are first in the field, hence that's why I'm a huge Royal Oak fan.
Just my 2 cents for what its worth.