Ok what I have read so far on the different forums.
The BP is a great out of the box rep.
- superlumed
- great pearl
- good case
- good dial
- great insert
- ok bracelet and clasp
- 1:1 construction, largely interchangeable with gen parts
The noob V2
- superlumed
- great pearl
- great dial
- good insert, BP seems to be better because of "deeper" engravings
- perfect bracelet and clasp, guys who already have one say it really feels 1:1 with gen. Top quality
- it claims to be 1:1 made like BP but we will have to wait until someone tries that.
So to sum it up, both reps seem to be of a very high level, I dare to say super rep, a combination of both seems to be perfect. But we need a full tear down of the Noob V2 for further details and to see if it is really 1:1 build.