Jump to content
When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.
  • Current Donation Goals

-update- [Ultimate Movement Review] Panerai P3000 super clone


Rolexman

Recommended Posts

First of all a big thanks to Toro Bravo for a lightning fast delivery and smooth transaction. You can't go wrong with him and he is definitely on his way to being one of the best dealers throughout the boards.

So here it is guys. My review and opinion on the new p3000 clone. I will not go into the watch itself because member Ale has done some very extensive research and has aded all the info to his 'panerai bible' so look it up. I will start with a short 'management summary' before I continue to the pictures.

This movement is not based on an existing movement. It has 2 barrels and the movement design mimics the genuine p3000 design. It is however completely different. Genuine parts are absolutely not interchangeable. I have never taken apart a genuine p3000 so I can only go by internet pictures. If I would have to set my money on a manufacturer of the p3000 clone it would be the factory that produces the IWC Jones movement. In terms of finishing and design I get the same vibe. Besides both barrels the movement was oiled properly and clean. Parts were finished well according to rep standards. Some plating issues here and there and discolouration of metal. But when dealing with Chinese movements this is normal and it does not affect long term reliability. The p3000 clone was easy to take apart and is absolutely serviceable. Getting it back together is a different story. The gear train is extremely wobbly and the gear train plate very difficult to assemble. You need a special tweezer in order to reach all the gears and align them properly with the jewels. It was perhaps the hardest bridge I have ever had to install. Especially because spare parts are non existent. So if you break one little pivot say bye bye to the movement. Also because most jewel holes lay very deep it is almost impossible to see what you are doing when oiling them. Even with a 10x loupe you are almost working in the dark... But when finished this movement runs like a champ and I see no reason why it would be any less reliable than an 6497. I think this p3000 clone is on par. I can not yet comment of the power reserve as I immediately torn the movement apart to review but I suspect it will reach those 72h without a problem.

The details:

When I first saw the p3000 when it came out a couple of weeks ago I was very excited. The p9000 clones could not get my motor started as they did not clone any of it's functions. Only the aesthetics was looked after with some decorative plates. A pig in a dress or whatever you want to call it. But this new p3000 clone however was a whole different story. I could clearly see this was not based an existing movement (e.g. 7750/ 6497/2824 etc). So I did not hesitate and ordered one right away to review...

Upon arrival I could not take my eyes from the back. The movement just looks gorgeous.

31539C39-D2D8-4CF0-A158-2737F546E538_zps

9CE2DA4E-E7A5-4D74-B5D6-B72BD1454645_zps

Nice detail inside case back

493B3176-5612-4120-B0BD-1D986F11E4DA_zps

They even hid the ugly movement tabs underneath the pretty ones lol.

2AA9DA03-E171-42BC-B558-34934F3FB99C_zps

Before taking the movement apart I put it on the timegrapher. It runs at 21.600 bph and the amplitude was ok but rate and beat were off. As this new movement has a free sprung balance (so I thought) I was a bit terrified as regulating it can be a b!tch.

FC0D2368-2ED0-49CC-8260-E0DA8B59E4C6_zps

However upon closer inspection I noticed the rate stud hidden order the bridge. Thank god! That means the stellar screws on the balance are for show and this movement can be regulated like any other.

2AF11C43-9130-4D4C-813A-59341E7EF443_zps

Here you can see it more clearly with the decorative plate removed. An incabloc shock absorber which is also very reliable.

F82E1C63-AEDC-40A6-8CD8-66BEB0569C51_zps

Solid bridge and underside balance view.

DCF82AE6-2DD0-4B00-AEEC-EFFB846CC904_zps

Clean "POL" engraving underneath the balance. No clue what it stands for.

652E40EF-DC20-4086-98B8-4E2E3204E7F2_zps

The oiled barrel jewels

7C429008-8CBB-4CC0-A4E5-AAB75928D394_zps

6DF4AEF4-45D5-4448-8AE0-76D7606F185C_zps

Look at the 3 layered dial!!!!!.... That will need a special canon pinion right?

79B28BC7-6E2A-44B5-99AD-6AE3AEC92E45_zps

Huh?.. That is a deep hole.

2026AA3F-FEFD-4CDB-885A-E2320BA24AC2_zps

No special canon pinion but special hands. So forget replacing them..

04B24732-D81F-4DDD-AEAA-97A38EFC1A43_zps

Here you can see the base plate with the dial removed. Nicely finished and clean. No date option and a normal keyless which has some grease...

80DB6EFA-D789-4D84-8BDD-8420D12E7E32_zps

61585B14-BA92-451A-8C4B-A930B5AD2FC0_zps

Some part close ups..

98CC75B8-C020-4DFA-83FF-0329BD3B66AE_zps

F09D1488-8F6C-4435-BAF4-475912982037_zps

FE5716F9-D107-4992-9986-BE41A7B94965_zps

Here is the barrel bridge removed. Nice and solid.

D33436C9-E4D8-4632-99D0-D8E2B8791FE7_zps

The 2 barrels exposed

E20A41BA-6B22-44FC-994E-7BD30D4DBB04_zps

The underside of the barrel bridge (I used foil with this movement as the brushed plates are prone to scratches)

92FB1EC9-0C84-4FAC-8A40-EBF4EBD8582B_zps

Barrel 1 (clean but not oiled)

FCCAFFF6-B52B-44BA-B646-A6BB2508A739_zps

Barrel 2 (clean but not oiled)

570E72EE-C1C5-4992-B4B2-CF1E1B2A5A0F_zps

Here you can see both main springs. The barrel 2 mainspring is longer.

CCECAF72-CC46-4529-8F87-700CD9633394_zps

Here is the gear train. Completely different than the gen p3000 with a aded pinion to transfer the power to the top of the movement: the canon pinion (= minute wheel)

1EF21316-BA15-460A-8683-03D203AFDFF9_zps

The pinion I'm talking about

449A8C06-C084-4FAB-A0D2-229ED2AC8D52_zps

Other parts are also well finished

96093BBE-12BB-493D-B254-C8D36CE0FDC4_zps

33533E29-4D6C-44A5-B006-954880D56DB8_zps

Final shot on the timegrapher taken a hour ago after full service and regulation. Performing like a gen :wub: ...

5CDA9B74-6AC9-40E0-BDF5-2AACE04D0E3C_zps

Here is a genuine p3000 (pictures from Google search) and you can see the similarities and differences in bridges and gears.

0506EB1F-9A88-44E9-9C7A-7CE7F9F84D8A_zps

A83A653B-EF65-4EE6-A5B4-0F295C7B0E97_zps

4B0C2E3E-376C-4AA3-8CDC-381A42F53155_zps

Well that was all folks. Hope you liked the review. Based on my findings I would say the watch is definitely worth the extra $100. Although not a 100% the same in appearance and function as the p3000 it comes very close. Maybe the closest we will ever see? It is a reliable movement and it will give you that extra dimension of a genuine feeling. I'm still testing it so unfortunately I can not yet comment on the power reserve whether it actually is 72h. But I think it will come close.

Tanks for reading

Mark

  • Like 10
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just in. The new 372 with P3000 super clone movement. Brought to me lichting fast by Toro Bravo for me to review. Muchos Gracias :)

Stay tuned...

All I can say is WOW

So looking forward to hearing how this turns out. Looks bloody great regardless of the barrels and PR
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I just pulled the movement apart and I am so excited I want to share my first findings. Off course pictures and more details will follow soon.

Nothing on this movement is fake. Everything works like it should, is extremely well finished and oiled to perfection throughout. It looks as if they designed this movement from the ground up. Twin barrel and all!

Everyone who screams it is not worth the extra $100 is full of it. It's absolutely worth it!

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't get it, if this was built to replicate the Cal P3000 then why couldn't they at least put the bridge screws in the correct location and the gear train jewels are a instant give away.

 

I'm not knocking it as I think it looks great, I love the barrel bridge andI look forward to your tear down of this beauty.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks for taking the time to take pictures and share with us.  This looks like an excellent attempt and I hope that the next iterations will be even better.  As always, there is room for improvement (an to also make things worse :) ).  Did you happen to take a picture of the cannon pinion?  Does this version also have a cap that fits over the cannon pinion?  Thanks again!!!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 Did you happen to take a picture of the cannon pinion?  Does this version also have a cap that fits over the cannon pinion?  Thanks again!!!!

It can be seen on multiple pictures. The cap is of no importance on this movement. Read the review and you get your answer ;)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I did read the full review before asking my question. I can only see the tip of the cannon pinion in your pictures. I was wondering if you had one like the hour wheel picture. The cap was asked to further discuss the construction. Thanks.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I did read the full review before asking my question. I can only see the tip of the cannon pinion in your pictures. I was wondering if you had one like the hour wheel picture. The cap was asked to further discuss the construction. Thanks.

I see. The canon pinion is capped. But you do not see that cap because the minute hand is constructed with a very long tube and a closed centre. Presumably just plated silver. This mimics the look of a cap. Therefor the 'cap' you see when everything is assembled is not the canon pinion. I did not inspect the hands very thoroughly but I believe the cap to be apart of the minute hand which can not be separated. Have to look into that though. The way the dial and movement bond no other hands will ever fit.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...
Please Sign In or Sign Up