Hi Andrew,
I understand your concern but I voted "Keep it".
I am the opposite of you in fact: I love signs of wear as it trully adds character to the watch.
Of course, no deep scratches/dents nor serious damages.
But a pristine - LikeNew watch, specially a rep of course, just scream "to good to be true".
And by the way, for you Breitling fan, did you notice how fast the genuine AR of a genuine Breitling is damaged.
My friends one is worse than your PO .
Cheers
Stephane