Very interrestin thread Ubi.
I for one started to collect as many reps as possible because...I like watches and those I bought I really liked them.
Then, after some time, I realised they were "off" and needed to make them closer to their genuine mothers.
Finally I realised I was only wearing some of them and started to sell almost all my reps, kept frankens and got 3 or 4 genuine Rolex.
I will agree with you saying :
Would I buy a gen Tudor again? NO
Did I like it though? YES
Would I buy a gen PO? Maybe, probably yes! (ooops, we disagree!)
Will I continue to buy genuine subs: yes
And I'll add: would I buy a gen Ingy? NO
Would I buy a gen Daytona (Zenith, white face)? YES...
For me there is no doubts: replicas are the path to genuine.
All the best,
Stephane