Ronin and Nanuq make some very good points!
No doubt many Bonafide Vintage Watch Dealers will omit important details or outright lie about a watch they are selling...laser repair, movement and/or dial swap etc, etc.
Otoh, the vast majority of RWG members did not lie about any watch they have sold or traded, genuine or replica.
So...who are really the bad guys here?
It might not be us.
Nanuq: "We call them “rivet counters”, the people so obsessed with from-the-factory perfection that no detail is beneath mention."
If it passes the 'rivet test' what's next? Do the Riv Ctrs want proof the vehicle still has the original oil in the crankcase? Probably, if they are as nutty as watchnuts.
"Hey! are those rivets in your pocket or are you just glad to be here?"
Ronin: "There comes a time when aftermarket parts are simply a necessity."
Agree 100%. I have noticed ST and a few others have a whole line of high quality movement parts for rlx 15xx, 30xx, and 31xx movements. It was bound to happen since 'The Emperor' cut parts off and who can tell the difference anyway?
"Hey! that stretchy oyster has a fake rivet in it!"
It's all about the rivets.
I have only one used vintage rlx watch that I know for sure is all original except it has an inscription on the back. I've had a few in the past but stopped asking.
After all this, I am beginning to wonder if my JMB '1016' case is 100% original.
He said it was.