To get back on topic...I get my scent recommendations from women, not men. For evenings, this has never failed me--Shiseido Basala. Women (young and seasoned) have literally pulled me to ask what I'm wearing. It's hard to find, but it's my love potion.
Of course, GIT EDP (on me) is just fantastic and I've had the MOST compliments from females during the day. I have maybe 10 different bottles of cologne, but for the day...it's usually a toss between GIT, Terre D'Hermes and Vetiver (initially hated this). If you do buy GIT, buy the EDP and don't buy the cheap ebay knockoffs. I have and believe me, there IS a difference...