I don't think it really takes away from the OP, after all, if someone actually needs a rep to be perceived as a gen, then that is part of their expectation of the watch
Those're interesting examples, and of course, in the circles you're talking about, if everyone has the funds for a gen collection, when the cost isn't so much a consideration, I can see how a rep might be looked down on, but I think it depends on the circles themselves. As mentioned, I know people who could easily afford gens, but wear reps, and also know people who wear gens, but are totally oblivious to the watch in terms of brand/horological value, they just got it as it was a nice watch. I guess what I was meaning, is kind of along this examples: If I was to attend a barbecue in 'higher circles', wearing khakis and a shirt, if I was to wear my 6200 project, which actually looks like it is 50 years old, I would not expect it to be noticed or commented upon, but, if I was to wear the exact same clothes, but with a brand spanking new Ceramic Sub/DSSD etc, I would not be surprised if that would attract more attention, and possibly be commented upon.
[Edit to add] I think it's one thing to have a gen or a passable rep as a necessary 'work watch', and quite another for someone to want 'the Best Sub' just to impress skanks in a bar