Jump to content
When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.
  • Current Donation Goals

Lessons learned from an ETA upgrade


Pugwash

Recommended Posts

Recently, I won an eBay auction for 4 ETA-2892 movements in varying states of repair. Basically, it was 4 broken Raymond Weil watches, out of which I was able to make a working Gen for Mrs Pugwash and have a pile of bits left over, including two working movements.

The reason I picked them up was in the hope that I could transplant them into a Planet Ocean and a future BK/WM9 Sub I'm bound to get. Apparently, 2892A2 movements are drop-in replacements for 2824s. Apparently. Here's what I learned in 30 photos. Click to embiggen any of the photos, and sorry for their lower-than-usual quality. Taking good pictures was very secondary.

eta-swap-640-01.jpg

Both patients on the table.

eta-swap-640-03.jpg

Donor ETA 2892A2

eta-swap-640-04.jpg

To be replaced ETA 2824 from a 4th Gen 42mm PO

eta-swap-640-05.jpg

Take out the PO innards ...

eta-swap-640-06.jpg

Prep 2892 for new gen datewheel.

eta-swap-640-07.jpg

Remove old Raymond Weil datewheel

eta-swap-640-08.jpg

Fit white on black. Note the other 2892 with the dark red dial and my testing of PO hands. It's wearing my old UPO hands that I replaced with genuine parts.

eta-swap-640-09.jpg

Look at the difference between the rep and the gen wheels. I'd like to thank Ubi for pointing this out. Yes, I do have another for my 45.5mm UPO

eta-swap-640-10.jpg

Dial on the 2824

eta-swap-640-11.jpg

Oh crap. Recessed datewheel. Recessed pinions.

eta-swap-640-12.jpg

Look at the height on the 2824

eta-swap-640-13.jpg

Much lower on the 2892

eta-swap-640-15.jpg

Profile of the 2824

eta-swap-640-14.jpg

Profile of the 2892. Oh crap oh crap oh crap.

eta-swap-640-16.jpg

Height of the hour wheel on the 2824

eta-swap-640-17.jpg

Height on the 2892

eta-swap-640-18.jpg

Take a break. Here's a reference photo of a 2892

eta-swap-640-19.jpg

... and of a 2824

eta-swap-640-20.jpg

... and a donor 2892 (not an A2)

eta-swap-640-23.jpg

Dial from the Weil. See how thin it is?

eta-swap-640-24.jpg

Dial from the PO with ... oh, hang on. is that ring removable? Pleasepleaseplease.

eta-swap-640-25.jpg

Yes, it is. That looks much better with the ring removed. Phew! Still not really enough clearance on the hands, but as this is really a dry run for when I get the gen hands, I can order taller wheels at the same time.

eta-swap-640-26.jpg

Oh, damn. If I fit the dial, the dial pins are so long without the spacer that the rotor doesn't turn.

eta-swap-640-27.jpg

Wire cutters. Snip! Better.

eta-swap-640-28.jpg

Next problem. The plastic movement spacer is for a 2824 and the 2892 is ever so slightly wider, so out with the files and skim off a mil or so off the inside.

eta-swap-640-29.jpg

Next, the stem and crown. This is another step I'm allowed to botch as I have a gen tube and am getting a gen crown later. The 4th Gen crown and tube are not very realistic at all. Yes, I use a spare drill chuck as a pin vise. I bought a pack of three long stems for the 2892 so if I make a mistake, I know not to cut it that short again. Luckily, I got the cut exactly right.

eta-swap-640-30.jpg

Hands on, they're a bit close to the dial, but they do work.

eta-swap-640-31.jpg

The watch with its old movement.

eta-swap-640-32.jpg

On the wrist. Note UPO in the background.

There were several points where I thought it was not going to be possible to get it finished. Luckily I managed. I'm going to monitor the patient for a few days in case the hands drag or catch anything. Next, new hands and taller wheels! Oh, and a gen dial if the hands scratch this one.

Comments?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Some of you guys plumb amaze me.

Don't for a minute think I'm even close to being in the same class as some of our modders. I'm a rank amateur with a 70% hit rate at best.

It's why I won't do mods for anyone else now, because I reckon I'll get it wrong often enough for it to cost me more than I'd make. It's ok to botch my own stuff and take a few weeks over it, but there's no way I can make a business out of it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This job inspired me to look at one of the two remaining 2892s. One was cannibalised for spares and the other seemed to stop for no reason.

Armed with this: http://pugwash.info/eta/2892A2/2892A2.html I decided to have a look. I got to do stuff I'd never considered, knowing both movements were going to be chucked in the parts bin, and I even removed the escapement and winding sections. To make this fun adventure even better, I found the problem was that the pallet fork wobbled across the vertical. Rather than work out why, I stripped the cannibalised movement for the pallet fork and pallet bridge and fitted them. After reassembling, everything worked.

I now feel confident that I could strip a 2892 if I had a cleaner. Such a great feeling.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well done and well documented.

Only until you have attempted a job like this and tried to photograph it along the way, can you appreciate how difficult it is to stop what your doing and get the camera out...

I set the camera up beforehand on a tripod with the cable release to hand. I find photographing my work relaxing and it stops me getting stressed when it gets fiddly. If I didn't have a tripod and lighting (the area I work at is also where I take my watch photos) then this would be near impossible.

And yes, if I had to stop half-way through and set up the camera, then no, I wouldn't do it. It's only because I had it all set up before I opened the first caseback that it was done.

Thanks for the kind comments, The Zigmeister. We are all your students.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

One day later. The hands did indeed catch on the Omega logo, but refitting them with some cleveritude (lightly curving the hands up) worked wonders. The smoothness of the sweep is quite incredible, especially from 18" away. Sure, like all our watches, you can see the ticks up close, but moving the watch away from your face, they disappear sooner with the 2892. It's keeping ok time (a minute or so in 24 hours) but that can be regulated given time.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Wow, that's amazing!

When I see posts like this, I think, "I could try that......".

But then I realise that if I had the inspiration, ability, patience and nerve, then I already would have :unsure:

Thank you Pugs for diving in where others wish they could, and for having the generosity to document it for those who follow :thumbsupsmileyanim:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Wow, that's amazing!

When I see posts like this, I think, "I could try that......".

That's how it all started for me.

I've made my fair share of mistakes along the way, and I'm still an untrained fumbling amateur, but here's something I realised when I hit my 20s: There is nothing that one normal person can do that you cannot yourself do if you put your mind to it. Sure, you'll not be Zigaroonie in a day , or maybe even ever, but that doesn't mean you can't learn something as basic as a datewheel change or even fixing the keyless works on a 2836. There's absolutely no magic to it. As long as you've got a pair of steady hands and at least one working eye, you can learn how to uncase a movement, remove the hands and dial and get stuck in.

The only resources I used to learn how to do this was this very forum (and RepGeek to some degree) and a pirated PDF of the Timezone course. The forum was more useful than the TZ course.

If I can do it, I'm sure as hell that a lot more people out there can.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...

Comments?

Amazing. Gave me a change to see what the guys were talking about regarding a movement change and the level of difficulty; But as you demonstrated, patience is a necessary tool in everyone's toolbox.

Congrats on the successful movement swap, now I am even more fearful of destroying my movement when I try and shove it into a Submariner rep :bangin:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Nice job and write up.

Just curious, how is the stem alignment with the 2892-A2 in 2824-2 case? If I do my math, the difference between the 2824-2 and 2892 is 0.30mm. Any issues with binding? If so, the way to fix it would be for a 0.30mm thick spacer between the dial and rehaut to allow the movement to line up with the case tube.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Holy crap - you are really getting serious about this. I know the feeling about figuring it out for yourself and even if you wind up screwing up a few in the process just chuck it up as tuition fees instead of ruined watches and it might not feel so bad. I can't imagine the feeling of a success for something so intricate.

Now tell me are you programming at the computer while you are disassembling a watch and also taking pictures at the same time?

Usil

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...
Please Sign In or Sign Up