Jump to content
When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.
  • Current Donation Goals

Crystals and New PT and Cartel Vintage Pieces


jmb

Recommended Posts

I thought I'd pop up some pics that better "explain" a problem with the later PT and Cartel vintage cases. It seems that in addition to the problem posed by the oversize compression ring/plastic spacer the OD (outside diameter) of the rehaut on newer cases is usually to large. If someone forces a new crystal, like a Clark, down over this oversize "feature" the result is quite often a cracked crystal. Remember, Plexiglas does not take too kindly to being stretched a great deal.

I received a PT 1665 from one of the Brethren for a new compression ring. The new Clark crystal had already been installed to the case so I was going to pop it out and discovered it wouldn't budge. I thought, "Uh-Oh..." I looked at everything under the 'glass and saw a pretty nasty crack with little vertical stress cracks all around the base.

crack 2.JPG

I measured the ID (inside diameter) of the crystal:

Crystal ID measurement 1.JPG

And then measured the rehaut OD:

Rehaut OD measurement 1JPG.jpg

This resulted in an interference of about .0105 which is about .006" - .007" too much. I have seen a couple with about .013" interference...

There are two things that can be done. One approach is to machine the crystal ID to match up with the rehaut while another is to machine the rehaut OD to obtain a more reasonable fit - I prefer the later as it makes future crystal changes more of a DIY procedure.

A fixture I fabricated with the same diameter and thread pitch as the case back was mounted in the lathe and the case was then screwed onto the fixture:

Machining OD 1.JPG

After the case is snugged up onto the fixture it can then be spun and the rehaut OD turned to the proper size. I like to turn to about .002" interference which provides a nice "slip fit" but won't fall off under it's own weight.

Machining OD 2.JPG

With this little issue out of the way all that remains is to make a compression ring to fit.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Nicely done, J! I especially like the fixture you created to mount the case up for lathe work.

As with most things replica, it's amusing to ponder why the factory would change the case specs to match the incorrect retention ring, but I suppose it costs very little to machine off less material when manufacturing cases instead of scrapping stock/inventory of incorrect size rings to make new ones.

The things they do to save a buck...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Damn thats cool JMB. I'll have to make an appt with you to work your magic on this PT1680 case I have here in front of me. I originally put a t-39 onto this watch and the crystal cracked all around the base exactly like this one in your pictures.

Stupid Submariners!

;)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You can also sand the sides of the crystal down a bit instead of taking metal off the case. This would be an easier solution for a person that doesn't have the machinery like JMB!

.007" is only .18mm...it will take not more than 15 minutes to do

JMB...are you sure it is a PT case? Because I never had a problem fitting a gen crystal on my PT case with the cartel bezel...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Dizz, I don't know if it's because maybe Clark's are just brittle or if this would happen with any acrylic crystal... I kinda wish they would make Lexan crystals - practically unbreakable, and are a bit more compliant...

Just send it on and I'll take care of ya...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Chi, I rarely saw this issue in the older/original PT cases but it seems more prevalent in the newer ones. I prefer to machine the case, especially if I am making the ring as the next crystal replacement would then no need any special "fitting" to be done. I have chucked up crystals in the lathe and increased their ID accordingly with a boring bar but once I made the case holding fixture it takes me about the same amount of time to do the case as it does a crystal...

Oh, I think I've seen this on the Cartel cases as well which leads me to believe they both come off the same machinery...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

"As with most things replica, it's amusing to ponder why the factory would change the case specs to match the incorrect retention ring, but I suppose it costs very little to machine off less material when manufacturing cases instead of scrapping stock/inventory of incorrect size rings to make new ones."

I have always wondered about this too.

I heard a rap tune through an open window while hiding out back of a replica factory just the other day...

You fools think we care about cases an' kits!

No Fool! Dat ain't it!

It's 'bout the cost of three-sixteen an' carbide bits!

Not fine finish an' proper fits!

That's for fools dat buys the real sh*t!

Uh-huh! Uh-huh!

:animal_rooster:

Edited by automatico
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I heard a rap tune through an open window while hiding out back of a replica factory just the other day...

You fools think we care about cases an' kits!

No Fool! Dat ain't it!

It's 'bout the cost of three-sixteen an' carbide bits!

Not fine finish an' proper fits!

That's for fools dat buys the real sh*t!

Uh-huh! Uh-huh!

:animal_rooster:

Cool.......maybe that's a REP tune, not a RAP tune..... :yeah:

Swapped a Clark 127 in my PT 1680 - no problem

Swapped a T39 and or a T19 in my PT 1665 - no problem

Both cases from original early PT versions.

BUT tight as anything to get on and off - so plenty of potential trouble!

J - ever thought of moving to Europe - such great expertise? :good:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

J - ever thought of moving to Europe - such great expertise? :good:

I'd like to visit England, Sweden, and Germany, but I think the politics most places in the "Old Country" are a bit farther left than what I would feel comfortable with as far as a place to live is concerned! :whistling:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...
Please Sign In or Sign Up