Which do you prefer.....

[Justasgood]

This........

Or this......

Thanks in advance,

Kurt.

[rower]

I'll take one of each thank you very much.

I would leave the first one on the bracelet and I would wear the second on a NATO strap.

[Justasgood]

I'll take one of each thank you very much.

I would leave the first one on the bracelet and I would wear the second on a NATO strap.

Yeah an Olive Nato......however, they are the same watch....top one is a NOS Gen service dial and hands for the 5513 and the bottom two are from NDTrading Re-dialed and matching hands.

[Stephane]

Well, I would prefer the non wg surounded indices but even the 1st one is looking great.

Both versions are looking great.

I couldn't choose, sorry to add to your own undecision...

[jsmith11]

Both beautiful watches but I would prefer the first one, the color of the markers looks sharper!

[Xyphis]

Not enough difference for me. They both look great.

Good luck in your decision

[Guest Solosailor]

I'd go for number 1.

Olly

[mrandazzo]

I'll choose the first one: surrounded markers are more shiny.

I like vintage dial, but I prefer modern submariner dial.

Nice watch!

[Cats]

Both beautiful watches but i prefer number 1.

If you ever consider to sell it i'm the one tp buy it.

Cats

[Slartibartfast]

It's gotta be the "or this" for me. I am into the vintage look at the moment. Great choices both of them though!

[its_urabus]

first one. looks great...

[vlydog]

number 2

hands down

[gioarmani]

The first.

[Jetsons]

Tough choice, Kurt.

I normally much prefer the matte dial but numero uno looks very good. I would have to see them in the flesh.

Hopefully, you have both.

[freddy333]

Kurt - I prefer vintage to modern & both look spectacular, but I think the modern version looks more realistic. I think the NDTrading dial is too smooth. If it had more texture, I would probably prefer it. A number of people have posted methods for adding vintage texture to a Rolex dial (here is mine) if you want to give it a try.

[luisik]

I choose your 1st one.

[eddhead]

Love the matte dial on the second, but the markers on the first are excellent. As a total package I prefer the 1st.