Jump to content
When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.
  • Current Donation Goals

Quick and Easy Cartel 5512 Fixup


jmb

Recommended Posts

After looking at the several reviews of this watch I decided it was probably worth that much in parts! My ultimate plans will probably put a 2846 and Snowflake dial in this case but in the meantime I'll just "age" it for a while. For the most part I don't buy reps anymore. If I want something I scrounge the parts and build it and this is in fact the first rep I've bought in about a year and my first purchase from Josh.

Normally "budget" watches have plastic movement spacers and other corners that have been cut, not so in here! I was pleasantly surprised to find the DG movement centered with a brass movement ring and secured with case clamps/tabs and screws. The case clamp screws had extremely shallow slots, so much so that it was hard to unscrew them, so I replaced them with better screws upon reassembly. Case back has very smooth threads and unscrews/screws in smoothly and the groove for the case back O-ring is machined into the case back instead of the case. The band is reasonable, with hollow mid-links and the usual sharp edges and loose screws. Every screw was at least 1/2 turn away from being tight!

My biggest gripe with the case is the short CGs, not much can be done about them other than putting a spot of weld on the tips and re-working. I suppose the CGs could get like this on an old well used watch that has seen a lot of buffer action. Even putting the crown on a diet doesn't help much. :( One other thing I thought odd is that the case is marke as a 5513 and I ordered a 5512 but I suppose it wouldn't be unheard of for the factories to use the same case for both.

The crystal retaining ring, it's great! The crystal retention ring is machined like the gens and MBWs I've copied with an angle cut on the bottom edge instead of a "step" like the PT watch. The tension washer looks to be stainless steel instead of brass which might account for the somewhat less smooth rotation I am experiencing on this.

The movement displays the DG logo/mark and appears quite clean. I put it on the timer and it was at about +3 sec/day face up and a beat-rate error I can live with.

I had intended to just wear this for a while but you guys are such bad influences I could only take about an hour of the tiny lug holes so it hadda come apart! I de-cased the movement, drilled the lugs to proper size, blended, and re-polished the case sides. I then drilled out the band and the end-links. When reassembling I replaced the standard spring bars with the more correct ofrei units.

I then planned on replacing the crown but found I was out of "good" 7mm Trip-Locks so I chucked the fat crown in the lathe and took off about .010" or so then milled off the top of the tube a corresponding amount. The result is a much better looking crown but the unfortunately, as mentioned before, it did little for the CGs.

OK, 'nuf jackin' my jaws so here's a couple pics after the two minor mods:

Here it is right out of the box, notice the itty-bitty lug holes. :yuk:

Wrist 1.JPG

Wrist 2.JPG

Here's what it looks like under the hood.

movement 1.JPG

movement 2.JPG

A good close-up of the crystal ring.

Crystal ring 1.JPG

Put back together.

5512 1.JPG

5512 2.JPG

5512 3.JPG

At least the clasp has everything spelled correctly!

Clasp 1.JPG

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Nice one J - very efficient update to a great value piece?

Maybe if you reshape them CGs on the upper face - make them less rounded and curved? They might appear a little higher is less rounded and fat?

I was wondering what the bracelet set up was on this one - that looks like the lower quality 93150 hollow mid link with the open 580's?

That crystal sits quite high and domed - what do you think of it? :thumbsupsmileyanim:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm not real wild about the crystal. I suppose it would probably look a bit better if it was "lowered" a bit so that the "dome" blends into the insert but I'm not really a big dome fan. I'll probably eventually put a T19 on it...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

movement 1.JPG

That looks like the same movement that powered my original POS 5514, which I picked up a dozen or so years ago. Although I replaced the movement 4 years ago with an ETA2846, I just wound the original & it is still working.

Hi This is my 5513 from Josh. What do you think? It's modded...

It looks almost like a gen to me.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You know J, I'm wondering if you shaved a little off the outsides of the cgs if it would make them look taller

Here's a gen

5513natationgeneva1.jpg

here's my 1680- skinny cgs coming up 1/2way on the crown

1680sub2.jpg

I think the problem with the rep cgs is they're too fat! Trim the insides (if required) and skinny up the outside edges.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yeah, M, it is quite a monster compared to an Air-King or Prince Oysterdate! ;) The vintage ones just feel rounder and smoother than the modern ones and it wears pretty comfortably.

Oh, and the insert snaps in, no glue. I'll probably give it a little Gorilla backup but I think this is the first rep I've had that didn't have a glued in insert!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm not real wild about the crystal. I suppose it would probably look a bit better if it was "lowered" a bit so that the "dome" blends into the insert but I'm not really a big dome fan. I'll probably eventually put a T19 on it...

That and the CGs would be my only bugbears as well. As you say though, a spot of weld on the CGs and a T19, and you'll be good to go :) As for not being a big dome fan, they do grow on you :good::drinks:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest jsuperman17

yeah that cg is bugging me as well... i looked up numerous photos of the gen and it should be a tad bit longer... i guess it looks different on the wrist.. does anyone know who can modd the cg with some welding?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

yeah that cg is bugging me as well... i looked up numerous photos of the gen and it should be a tad bit longer... i guess it looks different on the wrist.. does anyone know who can modd the cg with some welding?

JMB is your man when it comes to weld work :good:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Great writeup Justin and nice mods!

I ordered the same watch a couple days after you...should be here soon. I've been buying parts to mod mine too.

I wonder how hard is it going to be to put an eta in this?

Been told it fits ok and can use the same movement holder(im not sure about the movement holder) but the eta will fit!

These watches have options for eta , asian eta and the 2813!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

That looks like the same movement that powered my original POS 5514, which I picked up a dozen or so years ago. Although I replaced the movement 4 years ago with an ETA2846, I just wound the original & it is still working.

It looks almost like a gen to me.

2813 s then were only slow beat movements these are fast beat but the slow beat is the one to have for a vintage sub

its a workhorse movement and simple and reliable sometimes i wonder why we spend so much on etas although i do like 2846 eta

the vintage reps are getting better and better!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

After looking at the several reviews of this watch I decided it was probably worth that much in parts! My ultimate plans will probably put a 2846 and Snowflake dial in this case but in the meantime I'll just "age" it for a while. For the most part I don't buy reps anymore. If I want something I scrounge the parts and build it and this is in fact the first rep I've bought in about a year and my first purchase from Josh.

Normally "budget" watches have plastic movement spacers and other corners that have been cut, not so in here! I was pleasantly surprised to find the DG movement centered with a brass movement ring and secured with case clamps/tabs and screws. The case clamp screws had extremely shallow slots, so much so that it was hard to unscrew them, so I replaced them with better screws upon reassembly. Case back has very smooth threads and unscrews/screws in smoothly and the groove for the case back O-ring is machined into the case back instead of the case. The band is reasonable, with hollow mid-links and the usual sharp edges and loose screws. Every screw was at least 1/2 turn away from being tight!

My biggest gripe with the case is the short CGs, not much can be done about them other than putting a spot of weld on the tips and re-working. I suppose the CGs could get like this on an old well used watch that has seen a lot of buffer action. Even putting the crown on a diet doesn't help much. :( One other thing I thought odd is that the case is marke as a 5513 and I ordered a 5512 but I suppose it wouldn't be unheard of for the factories to use the same case for both.

The crystal retaining ring, it's great! The crystal retention ring is machined like the gens and MBWs I've copied with an angle cut on the bottom edge instead of a "step" like the PT watch. The tension washer looks to be stainless steel instead of brass which might account for the somewhat less smooth rotation I am experiencing on this.

The movement displays the DG logo/mark and appears quite clean. I put it on the timer and it was at about +3 sec/day face up and a beat-rate error I can live with.

I had intended to just wear this for a while but you guys are such bad influences I could only take about an hour of the tiny lug holes so it hadda come apart! I de-cased the movement, drilled the lugs to proper size, blended, and re-polished the case sides. I then drilled out the band and the end-links. When reassembling I replaced the standard spring bars with the more correct ofrei units.

I then planned on replacing the crown but found I was out of "good" 7mm Trip-Locks so I chucked the fat crown in the lathe and took off about .010" or so then milled off the top of the tube a corresponding amount. The result is a much better looking crown but the unfortunately, as mentioned before, it did little for the CGs.

OK, 'nuf jackin' my jaws so here's a couple pics after the two minor mods:

Here it is right out of the box, notice the itty-bitty lug holes. :yuk:

Wrist 1.JPG

Wrist 2.JPG

Here's what it looks like under the hood.

movement 1.JPG

movement 2.JPG

A good close-up of the crystal ring.

Crystal ring 1.JPG

Put back together.

5512 1.JPG

5512 2.JPG

5512 3.JPG

At least the clasp has everything spelled correctly!

Clasp 1.JPG

Hi JMB

Could you tell me, if I file down the crown to make it smaller and file the tube to match, do i need to shorten the stem?

Kind regards, Marc.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...
Please Sign In or Sign Up