I think the quality of this board lays in the indepth watch reviews, the technical discussions, the dealer QC feedback and the community feel (id. GTGs, wristies, raffles, donations to help a brother out in bad times), but I have the feeling that 90% of the essential posts are made by paying members. So I wouldn't mind that as a consequence non-participating members will leave to other boards (I prefer them to join off course).
I also think that marketingwise it wouldn't be a bad idea to have a more exclusive (i.d. pay to play) quality board to differentiate from the other boards. But maybe I'm taking this one step too far for now....
Anyway, I'll prefer quality over quantity (as I do with my rep collection, lol) and I would be happy to pay for that.
There have already been mentioned some very good ideas. So what about:
- access to member sales threads (reading & posting) for paying members only
- access to knowledge base & review section for paying members only
- access to collectors and collector feedback for everybody
- general discussion for everybody
- brand forums for everybody
- limited pic size, no avatar and no signature for non paying members
- if the software allows, a chatfunction for paying members only. Shoutbox for everybody
- non paying members can only PM other non paying members
- non paying member 'post of the month' gets free upgrade for 1 year.
In this way non paying members can find some general information on reps, where to buy them and experience some community feel. If they like this place they can upgrade and get access to the indepth quality part of the board. This will sort the weath from the chaff.