I think the criteria for the "Rep of the Year" award should be out of the box accuracy, and in the event of a "tie-break", complexity should be judged.
The price of the gen should not be taken into account. Also, there are a lot of people out there that simply don't like Rolexes, PAMs, Tags or Breitlings etc and, not to forget, there are a lot of HBB fan-boys etc. These biases should not be allowed to influence the award.
If there is anything out there that matches the SOSF for accuracy, then we should go to the complexity criteria. If there is a more accurate rep than the SOSF, the SOSF should be ruled out. Otherwise the SOSF takes it.