Great post, Dave. I've got my share of gens (9....and all expensive) and tons of reps. Personally, I'm a watch nut and never really cared if the rep was accurate to the nth degree. Guess I'm not anal. I enjoy the reps simply because I enjoy the design and don't go nuts trying for the "perfect" rep. PS. It doesn't exist......no matter how close it comes.
I'm still in the game, but my gameplan has changed. I don't go for the initial introduction. I wait for the subsequent version, and I only go for something that truly excites me. I've got reps that are three or four years old and still look good and run well.
All the "anal" stuff goes right over my head. I don't go crazy for relumes, since most of my gens (which include Rollie's, AP's, Breitlings, IWC, DON'T HAVE MUCH LUME left on them either!
Hope you hang around till you reach the next stage, LOL!