Caci - You are going to have to spend some money to get a dial & handset that look gen. Unfortunately, that is just the way it is. All the standard rep-quality parts look like what you currently have. Alternatively, you could have the dial refinished professionally, but that would cost about the same as a good replacement dial & may still look 'repainted'. Were it me, I would start saving for a proper dial - high-end aftermarket or gen - & handset. Also, have the 1036GMT movement properly overhauled when you replace the dial/hands. It is overdue & these GMT movements are not something that should be left to run without proper maintenance. Once the parts wear out, you will have a hell of a time finding (& need a second career paying for) replacements.