Oh boy! Happened to me a few weeks ago on aonther forum and it really threw my paypal account into a tail spin. Luckily, the buyer and I resolved it but the PP claim was opened within 24 hrs of the watch being received.
I learned a valuable lesson. Even though everyone deserves a start, I will now deal with veteran members and only if I cannot sell will I move on. I've always been a first come first serve guy. No more!
Hopefully, it all works out for you, Sneed.