I'm a dyed in the wool vintage Rolex buff and I'd never consider a contemporary piece, even if it was given to me free of charge. Horrible ghastly things. Until I saw the ARF SD43. Yes, I bought one. I violated my personal ethics and it lives in Chez Nanuq. And by God, it's beautiful. I've got absolutely no complaints about it save one: it uses a very "white" shade of steel for the case, and not for the band. ARF say it's 904 alloy just like Rolex, and they may be right. But the band is something else and the "color" of the steel is different than the case. It's subtle but it's there. Other than that, it's absolutely worth the money. It's solid as a tank, substantial, and feels every bit the part of genuine Rolex. There's nothing cheap or flimsy or tinny about it. You'll come to admire the case size as a nice step up from the vintage stuff but not over large like the DSSD. Really, what have you got to lose? If you don't like it, sell it on for a $50 loss. It's worth the gamble.