I look forward to seing how this new bezel holds up.
Just for your info - because of the way the case (Bezel, Case, Caseback) is constructed, the bezel can't be solid rubber. Actually the screws that you see on the bezel connect to the screws (which are actually nuts) in the caseback. Solid rubber would not withstand the force when you screw the caseback tight.
On mine, the bezel was rubber coated matte black plastic and with the rubber coating removed, it looks pretty much like before.