How does Woodford Reserve compare to Redbreast?
For scotch, I'd stand by my recommendation of The Macallan 12. It's a beautiful Speyside scotch that should not be offensive to anyone. Something like a Glengoyne is a common recommendation for a first timer normally, as it's less flavorful, and it's very light bodied. But, I'd say skip it altogether and try the Macallan. 50% of the enjoyment with Scotch is in the nosing of the whisky, and the Macallan has a great toffee and sherry nose to it with all sorts of subtle scents underneath. The nose on the usual "starter" scotches just doesn't cut it. I've got a bottle of the Macallan 18 yr, and at 3x the cost of the 12 yr, I've really got to say the bang for the buck is in the 12 yr. The difference between the two is very subtle. Just stay away from the Macallan "Fine Oak" series, and just go for the regular (and much better) stuff.