What do you mean by "Reps of watches $2,000 are useless." How is it useless? If the rep of the $2,000 watch is much higher quality/accurate than a rep of a $10,000 then what good does that crappy rep of the expensive gen do you?
Also, what do you mean by "For the price of a rep of a $2,000 you can buy the real thing." You can??
All of this does come down to, however, your personal taste, which there cannot be an argument over, b/c taste is taste. Therefore, if you like the not as high quality, not as accurate, rep of the $10,000 watch then I'm happy for you and its all fun.
Get whatever watch you want, thats the point of different ones. However, regardless of its gen's value, some reps will simply get "watch of the year" based on their stand-alone quality and accuracy.
Anyways, that said, based on the SOSF's build quality and accuracy to the gen, it def. deserves rep of the year, even if its "only" based on a $2,000 rep (which aint a cheap watch for most people, even those who love quality watches!)