It is generally accepted that non-Oyster (pump) pusher 62xx Daytonas have small recesses in their case to accommodate the pusher's cap when depressed. However, once or twice in the years since I have been collecting, I have seen verified, non-modded 6239/6241 (non-Oyster) gens with the larger Oyster-style recesses. Unfortunately, since I began collecting Rolex pics in the late 90s, I have not come across any more of them. Well, at least not until today.
I just received my Christies 'Lesson One' auction catalog from Nov 10 &, to my great (& pleasant) surprise, there, on pages 50-51, is a 14K Paul Newman 6241 with those wide, Oyster-style pusher recesses. As I recall, this watch ultimately sold for close to its max estimate (~$170k)
Therefore, my concerns about Goldie's case are now relieved