I think we're both kind of right brother lol..
I didn't see the difference between this pre 2014 and the 2014 dial, but what I noticed was that there are no red accents on the hands which would've implemented it to be the pre14 model, the hands were white what made me think it's resembling the newer model with the ceramic pushers.
Thus I personally would've used either the new ceramic pusher case with this setup or the red accented hands and sticked with the current case..
I hope I'm making any sense to you lmao, just got up writing this after a long night