What he said (Nanuq)
Clearly the red came after the dial. That alone explains why you didn't take it to VRF in the first place.
Lots of guys have come to RWG trying to show off their smarts and vintage goods. This is a place to enjoy these fine watches and share info, not to try and deceive.
I promise you... if you display your dial over at the vintage rolex forum, they will not be as gentle is the members here. Go ahead, do it.. and prove me wrong.